Rusya Federasyonu Parlamentosu’nun alt kanadi Duma, Moskova’nin Avrupa Insan Haklari Mahkemesi (AIHM) yargi sisteminden çikisini öngören tasariyi kabul etti. Duma’da yapilan ikinci oylamada Rusya’nin 15 Mart’tan itibaren AIHM kararlarina uymayacagini öngören tasari da kabul gördü. Avrupa Konseyi’nin karar organi Bakanlar Komitesi 15 Mart’ta aldigi kararda Rusya’nin AIHM’in de bir parçasi oldugu Avrupa Konseyi’nden atilmasi yolunda karar almisti. Avrupa Konseyi, Rusya’nin yine diger üye devlet Ukrayna’yi isgalini ihraç için gerekçe göstermisti. Rusya ise yaptigi ayri bir açiklamada kendi rizasiyla Avrupa Konseyi’nden çiktigini ilan etmisti. 145 milyon Rus, AIHM korumasindan mahrum olacak AIHM’e son yillarda yapilan basvurularda Rusya Türkiye’nin önünde sürekli ilk sirada yer aliyordu. Strasbourg Mahkemesi’nde 2021 yili sonu itibariyla karar için bekleyen sikayetlerde, Rusya 17 bin 13 basvuruyla ilk sirada yer alirken, Türkiye 15 bin 251, Ukrayna 11 bin 372 ikinci ve üçüncü siralari aldi. Romanya 5 bin 690 ve Italya 3 bin 646 ile 4. ve 5. sirada kendine yer buldu. Moskova'nin üyelikten çikmasinin en somut sonucu olarak 145 milyonluk Rus halkinin, bundan böyle konseyin yargi kolu olan AIHM korumasindan yararlanma hakki ortadan kalkacak. AIHM'e giden davalarin yüzde 24'ü Rusya'dan geliyordu. AIHM önünde sira bekleyen Rus siyasi muhalif Alexey Navalny gibi bazi sembolik davalar Rusya'yi endiselendiriyordu. The lower house of the Russian Federation Parliament, the Duma, adopted the bill that foresees Moscow's exit from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) judicial system. In the second vote held in the Duma, the bill, which stipulates that Russia will not comply with the ECtHR decisions as of March 15, was also accepted. In its decision on March 15, the Committee of Ministers, the decision-making body of the Council of Europe, decided to expel Russia from the Council of Europe, of which the ECHR is also a part. The Council of Europe cited Russia's invasion of Ukraine, another member state, as a reason for expulsion. Russia, on the other hand, declared in a separate statement that it voluntarily left the Council of Europe. 145 million Russians will be deprived of ECtHR protection In the applications made to the ECtHR in recent years, Russia has always been in the first place before Turkey. As of the end of 2021, Russia ranked first with 17 thousand 13 applications, while Turkey 15 thousand 251 and Ukraine 11 thousand 372 took the second and third places in the complaints pending for a decision at the Strasbourg Court by the end of 2021. Romania ranked 4th and 5th with 5,690 and Italy with 3,646. As the most concrete result of Moscow's withdrawal from membership, the right of the 145 million Russian people to benefit from the protection of the ECHR, which is the judicial branch of the council, will no longer exist. 24 percent of the cases that went to the ECHR came from Russia. Some symbolic cases, such as the Russian political dissident Alexey Navalny, waiting in line before the ECHR, worried Russia. Hukukihaber.net
Duma’da yapilan ikinci oylamada Rusya’nin 15 Mart’tan itibaren AIHM kararlarina uymayacagini öngören tasari da kabul gördü. Avrupa Konseyi’nin karar organi Bakanlar Komitesi 15 Mart’ta aldigi kararda Rusya’nin AIHM’in de bir parçasi oldugu Avrupa Konseyi’nden atilmasi yolunda karar almisti. Avrupa Konseyi, Rusya’nin yine diger üye devlet Ukrayna’yi isgalini ihraç için gerekçe göstermisti. Rusya ise yaptigi ayri bir açiklamada kendi rizasiyla Avrupa Konseyi’nden çiktigini ilan etmisti.
145 milyon Rus, AIHM korumasindan mahrum olacak
AIHM’e son yillarda yapilan basvurularda Rusya Türkiye’nin önünde sürekli ilk sirada yer aliyordu. Strasbourg Mahkemesi’nde 2021 yili sonu itibariyla karar için bekleyen sikayetlerde, Rusya 17 bin 13 basvuruyla ilk sirada yer alirken, Türkiye 15 bin 251, Ukrayna 11 bin 372 ikinci ve üçüncü siralari aldi. Romanya 5 bin 690 ve Italya 3 bin 646 ile 4. ve 5. sirada kendine yer buldu.
Moskova'nin üyelikten çikmasinin en somut sonucu olarak 145 milyonluk Rus halkinin, bundan böyle konseyin yargi kolu olan AIHM korumasindan yararlanma hakki ortadan kalkacak. AIHM'e giden davalarin yüzde 24'ü Rusya'dan geliyordu. AIHM önünde sira bekleyen Rus siyasi muhalif Alexey Navalny gibi bazi sembolik davalar Rusya'yi endiselendiriyordu.
The lower house of the Russian Federation Parliament, the Duma, adopted the bill that foresees Moscow's exit from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) judicial system. In the second vote held in the Duma, the bill, which stipulates that Russia will not comply with the ECtHR decisions as of March 15, was also accepted.
In its decision on March 15, the Committee of Ministers, the decision-making body of the Council of Europe, decided to expel Russia from the Council of Europe, of which the ECHR is also a part.
The Council of Europe cited Russia's invasion of Ukraine, another member state, as a reason for expulsion. Russia, on the other hand, declared in a separate statement that it voluntarily left the Council of Europe.
145 million Russians will be deprived of ECtHR protection
In the applications made to the ECtHR in recent years, Russia has always been in the first place before Turkey. As of the end of 2021, Russia ranked first with 17 thousand 13 applications, while Turkey 15 thousand 251 and Ukraine 11 thousand 372 took the second and third places in the complaints pending for a decision at the Strasbourg Court by the end of 2021. Romania ranked 4th and 5th with 5,690 and Italy with 3,646.
As the most concrete result of Moscow's withdrawal from membership, the right of the 145 million Russian people to benefit from the protection of the ECHR, which is the judicial branch of the council, will no longer exist.
24 percent of the cases that went to the ECHR came from Russia. Some symbolic cases, such as the Russian political dissident Alexey Navalny, waiting in line before the ECHR, worried Russia.
Hukukihaber.net